Rain Man

Oct 2 2018 | By More

★★☆☆☆     Clunky

King’s Theatre: Mon 1 – Sat 6 Oct 2018
Review by Hugh Simpson

There are probably enough fans of the original movie to sustain The Classic Screen to Stage Company’s touring version of Rain Man, at the King’s until Saturday. However, as a piece of theatre it never makes a successful case for itself.

Dan Gordon’s adaptation is largely faithful to the screenplay Barry Morrow and Ronald Bass wrote for the 1988 Barry Levinson film about wheeler-dealer used-car salesman Charlie Babbitt. Charlie only discovers he has a brother called Raymond when their father dies and leaves Raymond his fortune.

Mathew Horne (Raymond) & Ed Speleers (Charlie). Pic: Robert Day

The film is largely known, of course, for Dustin Hoffman’s portrayal of the savant Raymond. While the movie undoubtedly did a great deal to raise the subject of autism, there are many troubling things about the way the character is depicted. You would certainly hope that, thirty years on, different choices would be made.

So it is disappointing that this production – as the name of Bill Kenwright’s new company suggests – is little more than a retread of the film.

One of the biggest problems in adapting what is essentially a road movie for the stage is that the genre is so unsuited to the theatre. Important events happen offstage and are merely referenced; what remains is a series of static episodes that are linked by unnecessarily clunky scene changes. Jonathan O’Boyle’s direction is disappointingly pedestrian; even though this is a relatively short play, it does not exactly fly by.

Matthew Horne’s Raymond, meanwhile, is rooted in another era. Perhaps rights issues preclude a more nuanced revision of the character, but his performance rarely amounts to more than a series of verbal and physical tics.

an astonishingly sustained feat of acting

On a purely technical level, it is an astonishingly sustained feat of acting, but it fails to make much emotional impact, and he is too much a figure of fun too often. Thirty years suddenly seems a very long time in the way neurodiversity is portrayed.

L-R Ed Speleers (Charlie), Mathew Horne (Raymond), Adam Lilley (Dr Marston) & Elizabeth Carter (Susan) Photo By Robert Day

Ed Speleers (Charlie), Mathew Horne (Raymond), Adam Lilley (Dr Marston) & Elizabeth Carter (Susan). Pic: Robert Day

The other performances do not help a great deal. Downtown Abbey’s Ed Speleers, in his stage debut as Charlie, seems out of his depth. He is not helped by this version of the narrative affording little opportunity for the believable redemption of a thoroughly dislikeable individual, but Speleers never seems sure how to pitch the character.

Elizabeth Carter is on even more of a hiding to nothing as Charlie’s girlfriend Susan, a role that is desperately underwritten. That Carter is doing her best is shown by the impact of her scene with Horne in the second half, which provides the one moment of real depth on show. Too often, however, Carter and Speleers are both reduced to shouting as a substitute for emotion.

Adam Lilley and Neil Roberts attempt to provide some much-needed heft as the various authority figures, but the characters are little more than ciphers. Mairi Barclay’s roles are comedy stereotypes but are at least discharged with fun and energy.

That all of this is little more than a 1980s tribute act is reinforced by the hair metal and soft rock that underscore the interminable scene changes at considerable volume. This reinforces the feel of a period piece that has no particularly urgent reason to be revived.

Running time: Two hours and 10 minutes (including one interval)
King’s Theatre, 2 Leven Street EH3 9LQ.
Monday 1 – Saturday 6 October 2018.
Evenings: 7.30pm; Weds, Sat matinees: 2.30pm.
Tickets: Click here to buy tickets online.

Tour website: www.kenwright.com.

Rain Man on tour:
1 – 6 Oct Edinburgh 
Kings Theatre
0131 529 6000 Book online
8 – 13 Oct Cambridge
Arts Theatre
01223 503333 Book online
15 – 20 Oct Brighton 
Theatre Royal
0844 871 7650 Book online
22 – 27 Oct Guildford 
Yvonne Arnaud
01483 44 00 00 Book online
29 Oct – 3 Nov Leeds 
Grand Theatre
0844 848 2700 Book online
5 – 10 Nov Richmond 
Richmond Theatre
0844 871 7651 Book online
12 – 17 Nov Derby 
Derby Theatre
01332 59 3939 Book online
19 – 24 Nov Northampton
Royal & Derngate
01604 624 811 Book online
Tour continues 2019:
21 – 26 Jan 2019 Woking
New Victoria
0844 871 7645 Book online
11 – 16 March 2019 Salford
Lowry Theatre
08432 086000 Book online
19 – 23 March 2019 High Wycombe
Wycombe Swan
01494 512000 Book online
25 – 30 March 2019 Glasgow
Theatre Royal
0844 871 7647 Book online


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments (1)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Marion Miller says:

    Myself and all the other members of the audience who gave this production a standing ovation on Monday night must have seen a different show to this critic